Turkey Uprising updates


Note: This is a copy-paste compilation of whatever I could find on the Internet.



I am updating this all day long (June 4th).

Further news in English available in the followings:
  • Also, on Twitter: #resistaksim #occupygezi #direngeziparkı 


*  (16h30) Turkish Medical Association: There are 1500 injured in Istanbul, and 3500 all around Turkey.


* Testimony:

- Is that road safe?
- No, there is police on that side.


* From Facebook:

Friends, you heard Arınç's speech. Police hasn't slept for 5 days. Please, everyone, bring your own teargas and apply it to your own eyes tonight.


* Repost from Occupy Gezi:
Izmir Police Headquarters announced that the group of people who attacked protestors with sticks was undercover cops. Weird statement: no information on why they did it or if they will be punished for it.

* Çağlayan Palace of Justice occupied in İstanbul, lawyers demanding justice.


* (R)evolution of a protester, day by day.



* (15h30) Police in Ankara totally insane. (They have lost all their hope of suppressing this.)
Police threw blast bomb to high school students.


* Our dear marginal grandma, Facebook video.


* More of Bülent Arınç (President of the Assembly):

"The press outside Turkey making non-objective broadcasts. They're not sensible like the Turkish Media. Same things happen in UK, Spain, Italy, Greece. Our government and state is strong, We won't be deterred by the street. We'll take care of it."

It's nice to hear they take us (we = those who cannot be on the streets of Turkey) seriously too.


* Kayseri:



* Testimony:

Journalist: Why did you destroy the AKP [government party] building?
Protester in İzmir: Oh well, we gonna build a shopping mall instead.


* Know your enemy reloaded:

Bülent Arınç (President of the Assembly) still doesn't get it. He stated:

- 244 Policeman, 60 civilian wounded [Ankara Chamber of Medicines announced 414 wounded in only in Ankara on Sunday]

- Not many people under custody [An MP declared 1500 only on Sunday at Ankara.]


- I want to thank everyone for their common sense and our Police for performing their duty.

-   The police is ... taking action exactly according to our commands.


* Repost from Facebook:


The last message of 22-year-old Abdullah Cömert, killed by the police yesterday in Armutlu, was so impressive: "We will die in the streets for the revolution."
Here’s the message:

I only got five hours of sleep in three days. I was exposed to gas bombs so many times. Three times I had a close brush with death. And do you know what people say: ‘Is it you to save the country?’ Yes. Even if we can’t save it, we will die for it. (I am so much tired. For three days, I am standing with seven energy drinks and nine pain pills. I have got a hoarse voice but I am still on the streets since six o’clock in the morning. Just for the revolution!



From here upwards is June 4th


* Turkish Medical Association calls all medical doctors to abandon their routine work and rush to help the citizens who are subjected to brutal violence on the street.


* By 23h00 yesterday night (June 3rd) protesters in Taksim reached some one hundred thousand. In addition, in various neighbourhoods (could count 10 or so) the people were on the streets.


* Reported: Police brought water cannons from Diyarbakır (Amed) to Ankara.
 

* Protests (and police attacks) continued all night long in Ankara.


* Murderers! In Antakya, Abdullah Cömert was killed by the police



* Never thought I'd wish to be in Ankara: According to twitter posts, at least 5 barricades are formed by our comrades. Nonstop police attacks. Especially in front of the US Embassy.


* Reported: Police uses a "strange" gas in Ankara today, not familiar to the protesters.


* (20h30) İstanbul: Police launched a charge towards Taksim.


* Ankara: Helicopters spotting protesters.

Reported: Police pretends to retreat to lead the protesters into a trap.


* Ankara live streaming, several options here.


* Ankara testimony (20h00) :

Please be aware that there is an ongoing continuum in Ankara. It's hard to say it's a protest, it's more likely a war..Sakarya, Kızılay, Tunus, Bestekar, Tunalı..Police attacks to civils everywhere. One side have machines, riot control vehicles, tear gas guns..The other has even no stick..This is not an intervention for the good of the society, this is an attack to the society..The police shoot tear bombs inside the shops..Here is not like a festival, here is really rough.

* Roger Waters sent a solidarity message.


* A country on fire:

Adana: Thousands marched in solidarity. 250 detained.

Antalya: Municipality refused to provide water for the pressurized water tanks.


* Play Tayyip free fall, and go back to the street.


* Sorry to have missed this one: Syrian Information Minister invited Tayyip to resignation and to go to exile in Doha.


* When "people" rise, "economy" falls. This is a universal law of political economy.




* We are collecting evidence for police violence here. Your enemy knows you. Know your enemy.


* (19h30) Lawyers arrived to Taksim. "Lawyers are here, where is justice?"


* Ankara (19h30) Police attacked the Chamber of Architects, where the injured are treated. Protesters resisted. Police retreated. The march continues all around Ankara.



* Testimony of the first three days by Kıvanç Eliaçık, International Relations Director in DİSK.




* (19h00) Ankara update:  Police attacking to kill in Ankara. Protesters holding the fronts.


* (19h00) AKP Ankara branch: website down. Nice job RedHack.


* RedHack announced they will publish documents of the Police Department in an hour's time, as a response to the last photo sent from Ankara.


* Flash news (19h00): Protesters marching to the parliament in Ankara !


* RedHack hacked the following websites: Presidency, İstanbul Police Department, İstanbul Governorship, Ankara Municipality.


* From twitter: "Man, when the guy [referring to Tayyip, the PM] said we were marginals, he had a point. It's 1 am and we are wandering around in Beşiktaş with underwater goggles. We are the kings of marginality."


* Correction: The call for general strike was done by KESK and DİSK (revolutionary workers' unions confederation), and not just by KESK.


* A complete list of media corporations that ignored / are ignoring ( / have been ignoring ) the uprisings are shared in social media.


* (19h00) Students united in Ankara. Police attacks continue.




* Mehmet Ayvalıtaş (SODAP, Socialist Solidarity Platform) murdered by the police.



* In different parts of Istanbul and in fact all Turkey, protesters are marching towards TV channel headquarters and to government party buildings.


* General strike call for June 4 and June 5 from KESK, the public workers' union.




* I had to change the title of this post from "Taksim riots update" to "Turkey uprising updates", for obvious reasons.




* Tayyip talks too much:



 
* Repost from Occupy Gezi:

 Turkcell a private and biggest mobile network in Turkey states that they received orders and political pressure from the ruling party AKP and government to block the communications in Istanbul mainly Taksim square which they obeyed as well as the other 2 main networks! 

Turkcell and other main mobile network operators disabled the service in many other cities as the protests grew.


* Interview with an independent blogger, here in English.


* İzmir: Ege University rectorate occupied.




* Trabzon: Karadeniz Technical University. 5000 students marching.




* (update 17h30)
İstanbul: Protesters are marching to Taksim from all directions, once again.
Ankara: Police attack to protesters reported.


* Conflicts in Beşiktaş, İstanbul continued all night long.




*  Taksim Solidarity Platform disclaimer: These [see below] are not our demands. This is how it's going to be. These are not our demands, these are the terms of the people.


* Protesters were camping in Taksim, İstanbul all night long. (July 2nd) Almost constant fight against the police.



* Ankara (14h00): Tens of thousands marching and fighting against the police all around the city.


* Ankara: The detained are kept in a gym, as in military dictatorship times. More than 500 detentions reported.


* Some updates from Ankara (June 2nd):

- by 10h00, 416 people were reported to be injured.

- police left around noon, but attacked again at 15h00.

- fights continued all night long. number of injuries and detentions increased to an unknown number.

- here is one photo:






* (14h00) High school students in İzmir on the streets, demanding resignation.


* Out of the 400 detained in Adana, 100 were released.


* Police torture, reported from Eskişehir.


* Here are some live streaming options.


* Long live İzmir: Government party buildings (in Karşıyaka and in Karabağlar) burnt down at midnight.


* Antalya, June 2nd:






* I am not able to count the number of demonstrations all around Turkey. A very mild estimate is 100 towns.


* Police: You have 1 minutes to leave the space.
Çarşı fan club protesters: You have 20 seconds left !



* İzmir: Fascists attacked protesters with clubs. (June 2nd)


* More photos from all around Turkey.



* Taksim solidarity platform released demands [very quick free translation]:

1) The Gezi Park will remain as it is. We will not allow the destruction of nature and environment.

2) The mayor of Istanbul, the Chief of Police Department, and all the responsible who blocked the right to protest, who ordered the suppression and who exercised it, and therefore led to the injury of hundreds, must immediately resign. The use of teargas should be prohibited.

3) All our friends around the country who are under detention should be released without any further investigation.

4) All bans against protests in public spaces, in particular the one in Taksim, should be abolished.


* What is not happening (Yiğit Günay, soL newspaper):

- there is no formal media blackout (the corporate media doesn't show things by choice)
- policemen are not joining the protesters
- number of deaths seems to be exaggerated





* Tell me about your revolutionary militancy only after you are capable of doing this. Amazingly courageous protesters in Ankara. Respect.



 * Updates from June 1st. Photos and videos. Repost from this.


Man being shot with live ammo into the head (confirmed dead) http://s7.directupload.net/images/130602/oyxpcyd9.swf

Gun magazine and gunshells where he was shot in the head http://25.media.tumblr.com/8e0749b930a65cb0880a4c16d15afce7/tumblr_mnq6bwu8SH1ste7qoo1_500.jpg

Ankara: cops attack single man from behind and beat the shit out of him http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UPsPC4TPAMc

The insane gasman in the park http://alkislarlayasiyorum.com/icerik/123382/taksim-gezi-parkinda-herkese-biber-gazi-sikan-polis

Cops badly beating people in Bodrum (now longer and clearer) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c6JIz63J91o

"Come out, we won't hurt you!" http://alkislarlayasiyorum.com/icerik/124522/gel-gel-bir-sey-yapmayacagiz-diyen-polis

Riot cops storm TV studio (satire, keeping here for historic reasons) http://alkislarlayasiyorum.com/icerik/122653/canli-yayinda-biber-gazi-heberler

Water cannon randomly shooting at bus station http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=p9kVmrOtFnA

HalkTV Livestream (watch it!) http://www.ustream.tv/channel/halktvcanli

Some cool guy compiled about 6.5 minutes of footage that MSM has decided NOT to air. Too bad they uploaded it to their servers and he downloaded it (cop playing with loose gun @ 2:30). http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=769_1370155501

People VS Police Trucks in Izmir http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=701_1370132632

Girl vs 10 policemen (not my title, now clearer footage) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqQjPHtAZ6c

picture and video collections http://turkishpolice.wordpress.com/ http://occupygezipics.tumblr.com/

Anonymous stands with the turkish people http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdQYDR1GxJ8

Cop response to being offered food http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=IPfls2Ox06U

Protesters captured a big digger http://alkislarlayasiyorum.com/icerik/124575/carsinin-dozer-ele-gecirmesi-direngeziparki

Man very badly kicked by several policemen http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=GdeJX0qYmnc

Unprovoked police attack on peaceful protestors http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UiDRtvmd9EI

How your back looks after 20+ baton hits http://turkishpolice.wordpress.com/2013/06/02/police-govt-party-together/

Digger chasing police trucks away http://24.media.tumblr.com/8397cfb6906687c968d4ccf7de872e52/tumblr_mnsfk1P9FA1ste7qoo1_1280.jpg :>

Police teargas people who sought shelter at a mosque (disturbing) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZTmK6voEKo

Erdogan thugs doing their crap in Izmir http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=897_1370216510


* Why Uprising? Repost from this.

A Brief Introduction to Turkey Protests:

-How it started?

Police fiercely cracked down a few dozen of peaceful tree huggers trying to prevent a park from being demolished without any legal basis for building a shopping mall instead. Photos of the violent crack down became symbolic and people started to join protests against the police. Government tried to disperse them with more violence, so more and more people started to join the protests. A few dozen protesters in a small park became hundreds of thousands just in 2 days in multiple cities.

-Why they are protesting?

It started as a small environmentalist protest. But police violence was the last straw. It became a mass protest against PM Erdogan's and AKP government's authoritarian rule.

Here is a very small and summarized list of what happened during the 12 year AKP government rule:
  • Educational system was changed with haste, without any popular consensus. Many highschools are converted to religious schools without notice. Religion classes proliferated. PM Erdogan stated clearly that he wants to raise a devout youth. AKP government tweaked university admission formulas privileging Islamist youth from religious high schools.
  • Turkey became world's biggest prison for journalists. Widespread arrests were made claiming that they were anti-state terrorists. Erdogan also forced media to self-censor. Prominent journalists criticising his politics were all fired by the mainstream media bosses because they did not want their other big businesses to suffer.
  • Hundreds of university and highschool students were arrested and imprisoned just because they joined protests against high admission fees.
  • Violent crack downs were made in many public protests. They forbade people to gather in squares.
  • PM Erdogan refused to lower election threshold after collecting votes by promising it. He gerrymandered against locals wishes.
  • Displays of affection on public and on TV shows were restricted. Announcements were made in public transport to behave "decent". AKP even forced the producers to "marry" bachelor characters in popular TV shows.
  • Erdogan supported abortion ban. He relentlessly stated that he wants every single Turkish woman to have at least three kids. Day after pills are restricted.
  • Government restricted alcohol. They forbade consumption of alcohol in music and university festivals. PM Erdogan continuiously scorned and insulted people who drink alcohol. AKP municipalities removed outdoor tables and chairs of pubs from streets. They passed a bill forbidding to drink alcohol where it can be seen from outside.
  • Warmonger. PM Erdogan continiously tried to force the Western countries to go to war in Syria. He gave support to Sunni Islamists. Those Sunni Islamists harrased Shia minority in southeastern Turkey. He ignored it.
  • They imprisoned generals and military officers without concrete evidence. They detained them without evidence for years. Turkish people respect their military.
  • Erdogan undermined and disrespected Turkish soldiers killed in action in his statements. He saw them as disposable persons. Did I say that Turks respect their military?
  • Erdogan threatened to abolish the constituitonal court when he was denied after he tried to pass bills contradicting the constitution.
  • A drone attack killed 34 kurdish people in eastern Turkey, assuming they were PKK terrorists. Intelligence reports were wrong. Erdogan burried the investigation because it was his orders.
  • AKP government burried a lot of corruption cases.
  • Erdogan continiously denied requests from the Alevite minority to recognize their worship spaces as legal religious practice spaces just like mosques, churches or synagogues. He recently instigated secterian tensions, naming the third bridge which will be built on Bosphorus after an Ottoman sultan renown as a Alevite massacrer.
  • He privatized almost every single public asset ignoring opinions and objections from the public. He allowed destruction of forests and natural habitats to build hotels and residences despite objections.
  • AKP government increased internet censorship. Web sites were arbitrarily banned.
  • AKP appointed inadequate people as university deans conforming to its political views despite heavy objections from academia and students.
  • Parliament members and a ex-minister of the AKP shunned LGBT problems in the country and explicitly called LGBT people sick, claiming homosexuality as a curable disease.
TL,DR: Turks are saying to PM Erdogan: "You can't do anything you want just because you won the elections. Especially, don't interfere with our lifestyles."



from here upwards, updates from July 1st, July 2nd and July 3rd

* Taksim liberated (18h30) :






* Ankara 18h30 June 1st




* News arriving from all across the country:

A popular assembly organized in Eskişehir.

Helicopters attacking by teargas in Ankara, continued.

Çanakkale, Bursa, Manisa, İzmir uprising.



* More photos and text in Resistaksim.


* At 19:00 (Turkish time, GMT+2), all social media will update as "Resign Turkish Government" (Hükümet İstifa!) . Spread the word.

 
* (18h) Photos from Ankara here.


* Solidarity meeting Kayseri attacked by the police. Many injuries reported.

 
* International solidarity events from all around the world:
http://occupygeziglobal.tumblr.com/


* Prime Minister on Twitter (@RT_Erdogan) :

The leader of the main opposing party is telling that he is going to organize a public assembly at Kadikoy this evening. It’s his right, of course he can.

Yet, he should know that if he uses any impulsive statements, this nation will not forgive him and his party, CHP.

We can gather 1 million people where the opposition gathers 100 thousand, however we do not have a such purpose.

The timing of the decision of district courts on stopping the construction is very interesting.

We have never surrendered to gang, political body or mafia-like organization. We get our support first from God and then from the people.

The current incidents are obvious. It is said that the trees are going to be cut down at Taksim. 

I don’t know who came up with it, it’s made up.

I don’t know what these people want. If you want trees, come over and we will give you trees. If you want trees planted on your yards, we can also provide that. 

But it’s not the problem. The problem is: “How can we hit AK Parti?” No matter from where you hit us, we will stand erect.


* İstanbul: more than 1 million protesters in Taksim.

Ankara: Kızılay square occupied.

Samsun: Thousands marching to government party's building.

İzmir: Tens of thousands marching, the beginning of the meeting.


* (17h) Conflicts increase in Ankara. Social-democrat MPs injured by the police attack.






* Resignation calls all around Turkey.


* 4000 students in Ankara blocked the highway connecting the city to Eskişehir.


* Private ferry owners are carrying protesters from Kadıköy (Asian side) to the other side for the meeting in Taksim.


* Some 300 000 people in Taksim Square.





* Repost from Occupy Gezi:

AKP General Vice President, the ex Min of Education, Min of culture Huseyin Celik tweeted congratulating the main stream media censorship: "By the way, our media is going thorugh a historic test. Greetings and love to all..."


* Protesters report that the police put fire to the park before retreating.

Occupy Gezi posted the following:
There is a new and more logical conspiracy theory on the fire: Right after the government withdrew the national broadcast ban on the protests, fire broke out at the rear entrance of Gezi Park, making it look like the protesters started it. The matter of the fact is that police has been the one with firearms through out the protests and the gas bombs they threw has also started fires before.
We keep hearing from friends at other parts of the city attacked with tear gas by the police in Istanbul. It is also the case at Kizilay square in Ankara.



* (16h30) Ankara: Conflict expanded to all downtown. Thousands fighting against the police, 15 detained.


* Brutal police violence in Ankara. Police barricades destroyed by protesters. Police attacked violently near Kızılay Square.


* Solidarity meeting in Hatay (Antioch) attacked by police.


* (16h) Corporate media started live streaming, as other means of communication are already blocked.


* (16h) Reported: TWITTER CANNOT BE ACCESSED !


* (16h) FACEBOOK BLOCKED !


* Here is the story in English. Read how Turkish protesters tell it (with photos).


* Youtube blocks search for "Taksim" for last hour filter, only shows the Führer's speech.


* News agencies: Special protection forces allocated for Prime Minister's house.


* Taksim square and park counter-occupied.


* Police attacking in Taksim again: War tactics, I suppose.


* FLASH NEWS (15h): Mayor retreating. The meeting of the social-democrats in Taksim square got authorization.


* FLASH NEWS (15h) : Police retreating from Taksim. Protesters about to reach the park.


* Police exhausted:





* Today 8am : Public bus barricades the street to protect the protesters from pressurized gas tanks.





* Socialist MP injured yesterday. Today he's back in Taksim.





* A hand-made post says: Protesters can shelter here. No:6 




*





*






* Yesterday. Solidarity event in Eskişehir. Hundreds of detentions.




* Yesterday. May 31st. Solidarity meetings in at least 30 cities.


* Reported: Social media blackout expected. Keep vtunnel and ktunnel at hand.


* Reported: Police jamming the cellphones.


* Protesters twitting about how to produce your own gas mask.


* Reuters coverage here.


* Solidarity protest Ankara: Helicopters are shooting teargas bombs.


* Best video of yesterday (May 31st) Many important scenes, an essential compilation:
You can watch it on Facebook.


* Solidarity event Izmir. 2am:





* Protesters discovered a precaution: Write your blood type on your arms.


* 1 June 2013 13:26 video İstiklal street


* TV channels showed cooking classes yesterday night.


* Testimony (Aykut Gürlemez) [free, quick translation]. Dear prime minister. You made such a good thing for us, you have no idea. You ordered the police to kill us. But here's what I saw: I saw Galatasaray fans helping out injured Fenerbahçe fans. I saw students sharing their bread and water. I saw Kurdish and Turkish people walking shoulder to shoulder. I saw “whores” coming out of the brothels to give water and lemon to the protesters. I saw travesties opening up hotel rooms for shelter. I saw lawyers and doctors giving out their phone numbers. I saw medical students treating the wounded in the ER. I saw old ladies distributing clothes with vinegar. I saw shopkeepers sharing the wireless passwords, I saw hotel owners letting the injured to the lobby rooms. I saw pharmacies open all night long. And be sure, our eyes are full of tears, not because of your tear gas, but because of pride!



* Yesterday's catch: Football fan clubs discovered something interesting: They brought black spray and sprayed the masks of the police. The policemen had to take off their gas masks, therefore having some opportunity for "empathy".


* This is how one goes to a revolution:






* Solidarity meeting in Ankara: Police needed support from the army.



* Social democrats cancelled their meeting in Kadıköy (Asian side) because they decided to be in Taksim.



* Essential video of June 1st, morning. Boğaziçi Bridge.

- Note that pedestrians are actually not allowed on the bridge.

- Note that public transportation does not exist, by mayor's orders.

- Note that it is before sunrise !



* As for teargas, this is how streets look like:





* Doctors coming for support (May 31):


 


* Late at night. Public torture scene.


* It is reported that the teargas is not "pepper gas" but another weapon called "orange gas". Its use if forbidden anywhere in the world.


* Testimony: "It's extremely strong. You receive it and you faint. Then the ones on your back replace you."


* Istanbul 1:34 am: Video on Facebook


* Taksim at 3:40 am:




* From twitter: "We had our rest. If the police is ready too, shall we?"


* Around 30 enterprises around Taksim are announced to support (giving bread/water, or 24/7 shelter etc.) the protesters.


* Photos are updated almost regularly here:
http://occupygezipics.tumblr.com/
 

* What's happening in Turkey is much bigger than anything you could imagine. There is continuous tear gas charge for around 42 hours by the police. The protesters are fighting by substitution. The people in front resist as much as they can, and later replaced by the ones on the back.

Why Demanding Elections in Portugal is a Bad Idea


130414


This discussion has been showing up in several conversations. So I decided to clarify my thoughts about it and simultaneously share them here. Here we go: Why demanding elections in Portugal is a bad idea.


Premise 1. There are no real parliamentary alternatives to the existing government and therefore elections would stabilize the political turmoil.[1]

The polls do not show a drastic change in the political choices of the voters. Although many people disagree with the current policies, there isn't any parliamentary political party which has been gaining the support of the masses.

It is a typical bourgeois strategy to bring up the election option whenever there is significant dissent among the population. They would say “Oh, you have a problem? Okay, here you are, let's make an election.” to calm down the protests and reestablish their status-quo. Then, getting reelected, they would cheerfully declare “You see? The protesters are the marginals of the society. Democracy has spoken. The nation wants us.” Of course they would do this only in conditions where they knew that their power would not be challenged. According to recent polls, this is exactly the situation in Portugal. It is therefore unreasonable for the opposition groups to call for elections. This would simply strengthen the hand of the bourgeoisie.

It is now time to challenge the ruling class as a whole and the social structure with which it rules. It is time to challenge the existence of bourgeois organizations.


Premise 2. Portuguese elections are not legitimate, and social movements should not legitimize the bourgeois representative system.

Voters turn-out in Portuguese general elections are surprisingly low. In the last elections the voter turn-out was 58%. Here are the actual results:
PSD               22%
PS                  16%
CDS-PP        7%
CDU               5%
BE                  3%

This deserves emphasis. No nos representan! And you don't have to be a radical advocate of direct democracy to say this. They don't represent us even in bourgeois standards.

The electoral system is happily not functioning anymore. Happily, because we have a social counterweight:

Hundreds of thousands march all around the country. 10% of the population is protesting against Troika policies.[2] And here we are, instead of questioning whether this should be considered a “revolutionary situation” or not, proposing elections?!

One million proletarians are on the street; it is an amorphous crowd, searching for something else[3]. And what will the opposition do? Send them back home? An opposition whose lack of imagination restricts it to the existing political structure has a name, it is called social democrat. Let us rather struggle for imagination!

It is no time to legitimize the bourgeois representative system. What we should do instead is to mobilize the society, denounce elections and its results, and seek for revolutionary creativity.

In short, I challenge the advocates of the “eleições já”: Do you consider the bourgeois representative democracy legitimate? Do you think that the society considers it legitimate? When would you be convinced that the population does not consider it legitimate? And by this last one, I am asking for realistic qualitative and quantitative measures, not for some cheap rhetoric. (I wonder what Lenin would do if he saw us demanding elections today.)


Conclusion. Demanding elections in Portugal is a bad political choice.

The elections are not a relevant political tool for us in today's Portugal. They can only serve for the soothing of the social anger and the reestablishment of the status-quo. Under any revolutionary standards, a hypothetical election campaign today should consist of boycotting the elections and fighting for a structural alternative.



Supporting argument. Organizations that do not have organic affiliations with parliamentary parties should not demand elections but resignations.

In this section, I want to focus on why it is in general incorrect for a non-affiliated social movement to call for elections.

Social movements fight for social change, independent of who is in the government. The government policies only shape their strategy and actions.

In this context, they sometimes demand the resignation of certain politicians, or even the resignation of the government. Furthermore, they may support one or more candidates in terms of their programmatic support for the social movements' demands. These are all within the context of a campaign strategy.

But demanding elections?

Why would a social movement demand elections?

I want to emphasize that there is an essential difference between calling for the resignation of the government and demanding elections. One demands elections if and only if one has an electoral alternative to campaign for. A social movement making politics for the benefit of a political party is an example of what is generally called embedded politics.[4]

The role of a social movement is to move and to let move. The alternative that a social movement proposes to the society is itself.

How it looks like: Are you in favor of LGBT rights? Vote for the right party. Are you unemployed? Vote for the right party. Are you angry about the privatization of water services? Vote for the right party. etc.

How it should be: Are you in favor of LGBT rights? Join our LGBT organization. Are you unemployed? Join the movement of the unemployed. Are you angry about the privatization of water services? Take part in the campaign against the privatization. etc.

Demanding elections (and demanding it já for that matter) is another thing. If there is an election, an organization might choose to campaign about it. But we should not campaign for it.

Here are some questions for which I can't see the answers: What is the political meaning of demanding elections in addition to resignation of the government? Which role do elections play in the strategy of your organization? What do they serve for?


Refutation of a counterargument. Demanding elections in Portugal is a bad tactical choice.

There is one counterargument that deserves mentioning as it is compatible with the political assumptions of this text. It agrees that demanding elections is a bad political choice, but it claims that elections are good as a tactical choice. Here is how it goes:

An upcoming election would yield a PS-led government, who would not challenge the capitalist system and therefore would have to play with the rules. This would continue the austerity measures, thereby creating distrust among the population for the social democrats, and resulting in the elimination of all capitalist options and the radicalization of the society.

This argument is valid yet hilariously weak. It not only makes the slippery slope fallacy but also is not supported by evidence.

In Turkish, there is a proverb: If my aunt had a beard, she would be my uncle. It more or less means that if you ask for too many things at the same time, you would end up having something completely different.[5]

Let us analyze the argument carefully.

Premise 1.  An upcoming election would yield a PS-led government.

I see very little evidence for this. Recent polls show that PS increased its votes just a bit. So, a government which is led by PS would be a very weak government.
But for the sake of argument, let us assume this true.

Premise 2. A PS-led government would not challenge the capitalist system and would continue the austerity measures.


I agree with this premise.

Premise 3. Continuing austerity measures would create distrust among the population for the social democrats.

I see no evidence for this. I cannot come up with historical evidence that could be applied to the Portuguese case. I also cannot come up with any qualitative or quantitative parameter that would support this premise.

PS made many bad things for the society and it still has some support. The reason is that a social democrat party is by definition the expert of rationalizing all the evils it does (as opposed to the liberal party, who is never apologetic about its acts[6]). I see no reason why they would fail in this particular case.

In addition to that, recalling my response to Premise 1, a PS government would be a weak government. It would clearly need a coalition.
The best case scenario is that they are supported by right-wing and therefore scapegoat the right-wing for all their evil.
The worst case scenario is they are supported by left-wing and therefore take the left-wing with them down the hill. As PS has more propaganda power, it would dominate the discussions, thereby creating a non-cooperative image for the left-wing.

Premise 4. Distrust among the population against social democrats would result in the elimination of all capitalist options.

This is not only not supported by evidence but also refuted by it.

There are several capitalist options at hand: The weaker trend is the neo-Nazi nonsense, and I will not increase their citation number here. But there is an awkwardly significant monarchical trend: recall the flags in the first Que Se Lixe A Troika demonstrations. Furthermore, there is a ridiculously naïve but extremely dangerous Salazarist trend gaining support among the population, which has already become visible to the naked eye.

I want to emphasize that these are capitalist options, and that they exist as real options.

Premise 5.  Elimination of the capitalist options radicalizes the society.

I don't see evidence for this. On the contrary, we see signs of hopelessness and submission. Elimination of the capitalist options may as well result in a society that gives up the search for options. And I believe it is more probable in given subjective conditions.

What we should do instead is to radicalize and politicize the society by our own means, instead of praying for the objective conditions to do it.

 



[1]         Underlying assumption: This premise is based on the assumption that politics should always be revolutionary politics. Bourgeois parties exist today, as the Nazi party existed in Third Reich. Their legitimacy today should have no meaning for us. Their existence and their so-called right to expression is against human dignity. Freedom to elect a bourgeois party for a proletarian is like a slave's freedom to choose slavery in Roman Empire. (For further reading, see “the happy slave paradox”.)
[2]          By the way, this might possibly be a world record, not counting the amazingly inspiring Cuban 1st of May celebrations.
[3]          perhaps for another world, as the now-not-so-trendy slogan goes
[4]          I do not in any way claim that affiliated social movements are bad. I think they should exist, and I think their discourse is much more honest than many other organizations. This is why the statement of this argument is carefully stated. And this is why this item is a supporting argument instead of being part of the original argument.
[5]         The English proverb is “If frogs had wheels they wouldn’t bump their botts.” I think a better translation is “If ifs and ands were pots and pans there’d be no work for tinkers’ hands.”
[6]          For further reading, see Michael Moore's essays on the Clinton administration.


Life as it is

* Why are you poets so fascinated by madmen?

- We have much in common.

* You both turn your backs on life.

- We both select from life.

* A man has to come to terms with life as it it.

- Life as it is. I have lived nearly fifty years, and I have seen life as it is. Pain, misery ... cruelty beyond belief. I have heard the singing from taverns, the moans from bundles of filth on the streets. I have been a soldier and a slave. I've seen my comrades fall in battle ... or die more slowly under the lash in Africa. I have held them in my arms at the final moment. These were men who saw life as it is, yet they died despairing. No glory, no brave last words ... only their eyes filled with confusion, whimpering the question, "Why?".
I do not think they were asking why they were dying, but why they have ever lived. When life itself seems lunatic, who knows where madness lies? Perhaps to be too practical is madness. To surrender dreams — this may be madness. To seek treasure where there is only trash. Too much sanity may be madness — and maddest of all: to see life as it is, and not as it should be!




Man of La Mancha (1972)

Illusion

130206


Take a breath. Everything will be fine.

Close your eyes. Let the visual reality fade away. Close your ears with your hands.

It's going to be okay.

Imagine. Imagine the past. Remember, recall, re-narrate.

It's getting better already.

Keep breathing.

Deceive yourself, delude yourself, imagine the past. Let the reality fade away.

It cannot be true, so it should not be true, therefore it is not true.

Keep your eyes closed, keep your ears closed.

Your memory is whatever you prefer to remember.

Imagine.

Keep breathing !

Destroy, rebuild. Forget, re-narrate.

Everything is going to be just fine.

Don't try to make sense of things, reconstruct your mind and memory so that whatever is left is completely comprehensible,
and nice.

Keep breathing !

It is an illusion. And that's okay.

Don't open your eyes. You can already imagine whatever is worth to see.

Forget, re-narrate.

Never try. Never fail.

Dream.

Don't move. Don't act. Acting would be a recognition of the facts.

Keep breathing. It's alright.